top of page

Lucky 13 Saloon: Brooklyn's Original Metal Bar Heads for Death Metal Country

Writer: Randall Wilburn
Randall Wilburn
Oct 17
6 min read

Two decades after opening, Brooklyn's self-described first metal bar is still pouring beer, booking bands and screening horror movies. Now its owners are building a second Lucky 13 in the birthplace of Florida death metal.

It is the middle of the afternoon at Lucky 13 Saloon, and nobody has to explain what kind of bar this is. Slayer is coming through the speakers. On the television above the bar, a washed-up metal band is fighting giant ants in the desert.   The movie is Dead Ant, the 2017 horror-comedy about a fading band trying to reach a comeback festival slot. The pairing feels almost staged. At Lucky 13, it's just the afternoon programming.

Plenty of bars hang a few concert posters and put Black Sabbath in the rotation. Lucky 13 is something else: a place where metal is the organizing principle rather than the theme. That difference comes from who built it, who runs it, and who still drinks there.

Horror playing over the Ladies room door
Horror playing over the Ladies room door

The live venue wall
The live venue wall

Built by the people who needed it

   Lucky 13 opened in late 2003 on 13th Street near Fifth Avenue in Park Slope. Owners Melody Henry and Jeff Blanchard built it themselves after Henry moved to the neighborhood and couldn't find a decent rock-and-metal hangout. Blanchard was working as daytime manager at Manhattan's Webster Hall at the time.

Roughly eleven years later, the bar moved to its current, larger home at 644 Sackett Street in Gowanus. The move turned a metal drinking spot that occasionally squeezed in bands into a real small venue, with a front bar leading back to a separate live room. It's open seven days a week, 2 p.m. to 4 a.m.

The owners didn't learn about underground music from behind the bar. Blanchard plays bass and sings in Brooklyn doom band Eyes of the Sun, which he co-founded in 2007 with guitarist Miguel De Jesus Jr. The band signed to Blacklight Media, the Metal Blade Records imprint, and released Chapter I in 2018.



Henry has her own history on stage. She's a former member of Unto Ashes, the New York darkwave and neoclassical ensemble, where she played dulcimers and percussion and sang.

That background shows. Bands need rooms to play, fans need somewhere to meet, labels need places for release parties, and touring musicians need somewhere to go after their own shows. Lucky 13 has been all of those things.



Bathory on the speakers, horror on the walls

With bartender Samantha behind the bar during Fermented Metal's visit, the soundtrack kept digging deeper. Mercyful Fate's "A Dangerous Meeting" came up, then Bathory's "Call from the Grave" from Under the Sign of the Black Mark, then some Darkthrone. Nobody was curating a "metal playlist" for visitors. This is just what plays when there's no band on.

The walls follow the same logic. Iron Maiden's Killers artwork hangs overhead near horror posters, masks and skulls, while Ministry, Misfits, Clutch and cult-movie imagery fight for the remaining space. There's a coffin hanging from the ceiling, too.

None of this is new. Metal Injection was already noting horror and sci-fi on the bar's TVs back in 2009, along with band parties, release events and a jukebox where Slayer's "South of Heaven" was reportedly the top pick. Skeletonwitch shot its video for "Repulsive Salvation" at the original location. Seeing Dead Ant run while Slayer plays isn't a gimmick. It's a house tradition.



What's on tap?

For a magazine called Fermented Metal, the first question was obvious: where does the Lucky 13 Saloon house beer come from?

  Jeff Blanchard wasn't giving it up. "The Lucky 13 Saloon beer is a secret recipe and we hold it close to our hearts," he told us. Fair enough. Some things are worth keeping in the family.

What isn't secret is the neighbor. Wild East Brewing Company sits on the same block at 632 Sackett Street, and its beers regularly show up on Lucky 13's taps, including No Pretense and Maggie / Ollie. The two have also teamed up as neighboring spaces for larger neighborhood events.

There's no branded collaboration beer between them, at least not yet. In a world where metal and craft beer usually meet through limited releases and festivals, Lucky 13's version is simpler. The brewery is down the street, and its beer gets poured at the metal bar.


The Doorman and the Booker

Push past the front bar and Lucky 13 becomes a working concert room, with a house backline, a Yamaha drum kit, microphones and its own PA. Recent bills run through underground metal, punk, doom and hard rock. Green Hog Band even recorded its 2026 album Live at Lucky 13 there.

The people deciding who plays that stage are the same ones taking your cover charge: Mike SOS and John the Doorman, better known as JTD.

   "We've been handling the bookings at Lucky 13 Saloon for a year and a half," they told Fermented Metal. Both took on event coordination after their friend and co-worker Kevin Scondotto passed away. "Kevin, John and I worked together for almost three decades in various places such as Castle Heights, Blackthorn 51, and Ace of Clubs before we landed at Lucky 13!"

So what makes a band right for the Saloon? The music comes first, Mike says, and he speaks as a musician himself. But the door is open wide. "We are more than happy to accept newer acts with less stage experience as well as open our doors to scene veterans, national touring acts, cover/tribute bands, and local and regional acts encompassing all types of heavy music." 


   A handful of trusted third-party promoters bring in different crowds. A band's history and draw matter, but less than you might expect. What counts most, Mike says, is working with bands "that make our event team's experience enjoyable" and who appreciate the effort Lucky 13 puts into making every show work for everyone involved.

   The door itself is a different job. Mike SOS collects admission during shows and says most people are easy to deal with. "We sometimes get randoms who complain about the price of admission but it's not as common as you'd think."

JTD handles the front door, and he's honest about what that means in Gowanus. "Working the door requires a delicate balance of being courteous and welcoming while enforcing the rules of the establishment as well as the laws of the state," he says. Neighborhood issues and nearby shelters add to the challenge. The tense moments come when someone has to be turned away: too drunk, no valid ID, or banned for past behavior.

Thirty-plus years have taught him to keep conflict to a minimum. "On the whole, most people are pleasant and are just looking to have a good time," he says. "I am always ready with a quick joke or humorous comment to greet people, and wish people a Happy Birthday if it applies."



Lucky 13, Tampa

The next chapter is already under construction, a little over a thousand miles south.

"We have the location in Tampa and are currently just starting construction," Jeff Blanchard told Fermented Metal. "We are hoping to be open by the end of the year."

Don't expect a reinvention. "The new location will be pretty much the same thing," he says. The difference will be local: Tampa's Lucky 13 will focus on the influence of the city's death metal scene.

   That scene is the whole reason they're going. Few cities anywhere are as tied to extreme metal as Tampa, the city that became synonymous with Florida death metal. "That's what brought us here," Blanchard says. "We looked at other places but Tampa made the most sense."

   He also sees a gap worth filling. "There is nothing like Lucky 13 Saloon in the Tampa area. It is very much needed down here and we are excited to make it happen."

   The new bar's Instagram, @lucky13saloontampa, lists its address as 8123 North Nebraska Avenue in Tampa. No firm opening date has been announced yet.


Living Metal, and more

There's plenty to photograph at Lucky 13: Iron Maiden in the rafters, horror posters, skulls, masks, a coffin overhead. But the collection isn't the reason to go. The continuity is.

Henry and Blanchard opened a metal bar because they were already part of the culture. Musicians still play the back room. Underground metal still fills the speakers when there's no show. Local beer still comes from down the block, and a secret-recipe house beer still comes from somewhere nobody's telling. Old friends still run the door, carrying on what they built with Kevin Scondotto.

Lucky 13 has changed addresses, grown into a venue, and is about to plant its name in death metal's hometown. More than twenty years in, the Brooklyn original still gets right the one thing nobody can fake.



Lucky 13 Saloon · 644 Sackett Street, Brooklyn, NY · Open daily, 2 p.m.–4 a.m.



Coming soon: 8123 N. Nebraska Ave., Tampa, FL



2 Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
Guest
Oct 20
Rated 1 out of 5 stars.

Lucky 13 is racist to a point. Quite literally.

Like
Guest
Oct 30
Replying to

Can you please explain?

Like
bottom of page